
Hoping for Britain to rejoin the EU with Andy Burnham? You may be waiting a long time | Timothy Garton Ash
British Prime Minister Andy Burnham has delivered a cautious speech on Britain's relationship with the EU, ruling out rejoining during the current parliament while promising to explore long-term options.
Since becoming British prime minister this summer, Andy Burnham has faced persistent questions from across Europe about whether the UK will rejoin the European Union. His first major speech on the topic, delivered at the Lord Mayor's banquet in London on November 16, 2026, has disappointed those hoping for a swift return to the bloc.
The speech, delivered with considerable ceremony, was characterized as both cautious and old-fashioned. While Burnham acknowledged that "we have lost more than we have gained in the last 10 years" and stated that "the hard Brexit we were given is not good enough for Britain," he stopped short of committing to any significant reversal of Brexit during the current parliament.
Limited Progress
Burnham announced modest steps to be agreed at the upcoming UK-EU summit, including easier access for food and agricultural products, linking carbon emissions markets, and creating a youth mobility scheme. However, he emphasized that all actions during the current term would remain within Keir Starmer's "red lines" - no rejoining the customs union, single market, or freedom of movement.
The prime minister indicated he would only "explore options for our long-term relationship" with the EU, "to inform decisions in the next parliament." Unless an early election is called, this means any potential rejoining would not be considered before 2029.
Political Constraints
Burnham's cautious approach is easily explained by political realities. Roughly half of his cabinet doesn't want to even mention Brexit, and approximately half of his MPs represent constituencies that voted to leave the EU in 2016. While the country broadly views Brexit as a mistake, there's little appetite for reopening the debate or a referendum on rejoining, particularly without the UK's previous opt-outs from the euro and Schengen area.
Old-Fashioned Vision
Critics noted how Burnham's speech relied on outdated British tropes, including nine references to Britain needing to "lead" in all its endeavors. The speech also strangely separated Britain's commitment to European defense and Ukraine support from other dimensions of European security that involve the EU, focusing instead narrowly on economic benefits.
Most puzzling was Burnham's invocation of Winston Churchill's 1948 speech about Britain's position at the intersection of "three majestic circles" - the British Commonwealth, the English-speaking world, and "United Europe." While Burnham emphasized the Commonwealth and downplayed the US connection, he overlooked how dramatically US foreign policy has changed under Donald Trump, affecting Britain's position.