
Facebook may have access to your entire photo gallery
Italy's data protection authority has fined Meta €805 million for accessing Android users' entire camera roll without specific consent, with the privacy violation continuing for some users despite changes.
Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, has fined Meta €805 million (about $887 million) for accessing Android users' entire camera roll without specific consent or adequate disclosure. The regulator states the privacy violation remains ongoing for some users despite changes Meta has implemented.
The decision concerns Facebook's 'Get camera roll suggestions when you're browsing Facebook' feature, launched in 2023. This feature uses users' photos and videos to suggest potential social media posts, but the permission system allowed access to the entire gallery rather than just specific images.
Permission Problem
Facebook's app requested access to the camera roll through a single permission that applied across the entire app, covering multiple features with different requirements. This violated Article 122 of the Italian Data Protection Code, which implements the EU's ePrivacy Directive protecting data stored on devices like smartphones.
The permission is preceded by a non-specific notice ('enable other features') which does not make it clear to the user that they are also authorising suggestions from the camera roll.
Regulatory Action
The Garante's investigation began in July 2025 after consumer organization Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti submitted a report. Meta had requested Ireland to handle the case, but the Garante rejected this argument because the ePrivacy rules at issue don't use that system.
Meta called the fine 'disproportionate' as it amounts to less than 0.5% of global revenues and announced it will appeal. The Garante attributed the fine amount to the high number of affected users (around 20 million Android users in Italy) and the duration of the incident, citing Meta's 'poor level of cooperation.'
Required Changes
Beyond the financial penalty, the regulator has ordered Meta to request consent separately for the camera roll suggestions feature. The company must explain to users how the data will be used and how to disable it, and turn the feature off by default even for those who previously gave blanket permission.
Meta must comply within 60 days or the feature won't be enabled for users who haven't given consent. The Garante is also preparing for potential follow-up actions regarding possible use of content to train AI and a new feature allowing camera roll content to be processed in the cloud.
User Control
While Italy's decision doesn't automatically change permissions for users elsewhere, people can review their own settings. On Android, go to Settings > Apps > Facebook > Permissions > Photos and videos, then select 'Don't allow' to revoke gallery access. iPhone users can review Facebook's photo access under Settings > Privacy & Security > Photos.
Meta announced an opt-in photo suggestions feature for the US and Canada in October 2025, which analyzes media to find memorable moments and suggests creative edits. The company states suggestions remain private unless users choose to share them.