![[Blog] Chagos: Time to think beyond sovereignty - Turning Diego Garcia into an economic opportunity for Mauritius - Defimedia](/api/images/proxy?url=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.defimedia.info%2Fsites%2Fdefault%2Ffiles%2F2026-11%2Fdeenoo%2520thumb%2520good%2520.jpg&w=800&q=80&f=webp)
[Blog] Chagos: Time to think beyond sovereignty - Turning Diego Garcia into an economic opportunity for Mauritius - Defimedia
Mauritius has proposed a radical new framework for the Chagos Archipelago that would separate the decolonisation process from the future of the US military base on Diego Garcia, in exchange for guaranteed market access.
The Chagos question has reached a defining moment in the history of Mauritius. What began as an injustice during the final years of British colonial rule has evolved into a complex international dispute involving sovereignty, international law, military security and the strategic balance in the Indian Ocean.
The International Court of Justice Advisory Opinion of February 2019, followed by the United Nations General Assembly Resolution 73/295, provided substantial international legal support for the Mauritian position that the detachment of Chagos from Mauritius in 1965 was unlawful.
The signing of the UK–Mauritius Agreement on 22 May 2025 was an important diplomatic development. However, the agreement has not yet entered into force. Its implementation has encountered difficulties arising particularly from the position of the United States concerning the continued operation of its military installation on Diego Garcia.
Decolonisation should not be held hostage to Diego Garcia
Mauritius should invite the United Kingdom to proceed immediately with the decolonisation of the Chagos Archipelago, without allowing the future military status of Diego Garcia to indefinitely delay that process.
I would propose that Diego Garcia be temporarily treated as a separate and special strategic-security arrangement, outside the immediate decolonisation implementation process, without prejudice to Mauritius's underlying sovereignty claim and without any permanent alienation of its territorial rights.
This distinction would allow the remaining archipelago to proceed through an immediate decolonisation process while providing the United Kingdom and the United States with a framework to address their legitimate security requirements.
Mauritius must become a direct party to the UK–US defence agreement
The existing military arrangements concerning Diego Garcia originated from the 1966 agreement between the United Kingdom and the United States. Mauritius was not a party to that agreement.
Yet it is Mauritius whose territorial and national interests are directly affected. I therefore propose that the existing bilateral arrangement be replaced or fundamentally renegotiated through a trilateral agreement involving the Republic of Mauritius, the United Kingdom and the United States of America.
Mauritius must participate as an equal sovereign negotiating party, not as an observer or a state whose interests are represented by another country. The new agreement should clearly define the military rights, responsibilities, duration, environmental obligations, security arrangements and dispute-resolution mechanisms of all three parties.
Diego Garcia must become an instrument of economic development
This is the central element of my proposal. Diego Garcia has considerable strategic value to the United States and the United Kingdom. Its geographical position makes it an important military and logistical installation for their interests across the Indian Ocean and beyond.
If the continued availability of Diego Garcia is essential to their security requirements, Mauritius should negotiate tangible and enduring economic benefits in return. I propose that the temporary special arrangement concerning Diego Garcia be conditional upon the United States and the United Kingdom granting Mauritius guaranteed duty-free and quota-free access to their respective markets.
This should not be treated as financial compensation or a goodwill gesture. It should form an integral and legally enforceable part of the strategic-security agreement.
For the United States, this should go beyond the temporary opportunities available under AGOA. Mauritius should seek a long-term trade arrangement providing comprehensive preferential access for Mauritian goods. For the United Kingdom, which already provides substantial duty-free and quota-free goods access under its Economic Partnership Agreement with Eastern and Southern African countries, Mauritius should seek stronger and more durable commitments, improved rules of origin and expanded access for services and investment.
The objective should be to secure duty-free and quota-free access for Mauritian goods, improved access for textiles, apparel, seafood, agricultural products and manufactured goods, greater opportunities for Mauritian professional, financial and digital services, investment guarantees and technology partnerships, improved market access for small and medium enterprises, and long-term stability and protection against arbitrary withdrawal of trade preferences.
The arrangement must contain safeguards
Any temporary arrangement must protect Mauritius against future uncertainty. I would propose the following safeguards: The temporary special status of Diego Garcia must not constitute a renunciation of Mauritius's sovereignty claim or a permanent transfer of territorial rights. The arrangement must have clearly defined review periods and agreed procedures for renewal or termination. The trade benefits must commence when the corresponding military arrangement takes effect. Any material breach of the economic commitments must trigger a binding consultation and dispute-resolution mechanism, with appropriate safeguards governing the continuation of military access. Mauritius must retain its rights concerning territorial integrity, natural resources and environmental protection. The rights, dignity, resettlement aspirations and participation of the Chagossian people must be protected through a meaningful and properly funded programme. The agreement must respect international law and applicable WTO obligations.
The military arrangement must not become a permanent exception to the completion of decolonisation.
A call for national consultation
The Chagos question must not be treated exclusively as a matter for diplomatic and legal experts. It concerns the future of our country and generations yet unborn. I therefore call upon the Government to consider a national consultation involving Parliament, legal experts, economists, trade specialists, security experts, environmental organisations, the private sector and representatives of the Chagossian community.
The Government should commission an independent assessment of the 2025 agreement alongside alternative negotiating models, including the proposal outlined in this letter. The assessment should examine the long-term economic value of guaranteed market access against the financial and strategic arrangements presently contemplated. Any alternative must also be examined for its legal feasibility and its acceptability to the United States and the United Kingdom.