Skip to main content
Belonging by Sonia Gandhi review – India’s elder stateswoman breaks her silence

Belonging by Sonia Gandhi review – India’s elder stateswoman breaks her silence

The Guardian
17 lis 2026, 09:26Business
Oryginał
2 min read

Sonia Gandhi, India's elder stateswoman, has published her memoir 'Belonging' with HarperCollins after a deal with Penguin Random House India fell through over 'an impasse over a particular issue' in the text.

By any measure, it is one of the most extraordinary political stories of our age: a shy Italian girl locks eyes with the scion of an Indian political family, falls instantly and steadfastly in love, 'transplanting herself' as a result, suffers soul-shattering tragedies, then takes the reins of power in the world's largest democracy. The Nehru-Gandhi family has been in charge of India for about half the eight decades since independence and the principal opposition to Narendra Modi's prickly BJP regime for the past 12 years.

Memoir Deal Drama

Publishers have been keen to secure the memoirs of the famously guarded Sonia Gandhi, soon to turn 80. When the chance came, the deal with the country's biggest publisher, Penguin Random House India, fell through at the last minute over what it termed 'an impasse over a particular issue' in the text, with HarperCollins stepping into the breach.

A Life of Discretion

As it turns out, 'Belonging' does not read as incendiary. It errs, rather, towards discretion and legacy-building. It is also, at its best, a heartbreaking story of love and loss. Gandhi's voice is measured and generally frill-free.

Family Resistance

The introduction to fellow student Rajiv Gandhi was 'a bolt of lightning'. Sonia's father, Stefano Maino, a businessman and WWII veteran nicknamed Maino the Lion, is described in a 1998 New Yorker profile as 'an unrepentant fascist' until his death. Wherever expedient, Gandhi maintains her strategic silence.

Stefano Maino is 'padre padrone' – literally, 'father master'. When he hears about his middle daughter's love interest, he brings 'his fist down on his writing table' with a shout of 'Basta!' And yet, he buys her a ticket to India the moment she turns 21.

Political Legacy

On the boy's side is Indira Gandhi, the daughter of India's first prime minister, Jawaharlal Nehru. Barely has Sonia landed in Delhi than Indira decides the pair must wed. Indira then manages Sonia's first pregnancy, directs the name-giving ceremony. Gandhi refers to her, factfully, as 'my mother-in-law', but becomes a devoted daughter.

Charged events, such as Indira's crushing of a huge railway strike, acquire a benign gloss. The 21 tumultuous months of the 1975 Emergency – which saw members of the opposition arrested, civil liberties curtailed, the press censored – are rendered with a brisk calm. Tenderness is reserved for the repercussions on the family in its subsequent period out of power.

Z.ai
Article written by AI
Z.ai GLM-4.5-FlashFree
Free AI articles150 of 150
No limit after signing in with Telegram