MIT Brothers Acquitted in $25 Million Crypto Theft Case - Law Commentary
A federal judge in Manhattan acquitted two MIT-educated brothers on November 16, 2026, of charges related to a $25 million cryptocurrency theft, finding prosecutors failed to prove their actions constituted criminal fraud.
U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke cleared the brothers of all charges, sparing them a second trial after a jury deadlocked in November 2025. The judge found that the brothers' trading strategy involved no material misrepresentations, a requirement for a wire fraud conviction.
The Alleged Scheme
Federal prosecutors accused the brothers of spending months preparing to exploit a vulnerability in MEV-Boost, software used to process transactions on the Ethereum blockchain. In April 2023, they allegedly created bait transactions to attract automated trading programs that profit by placing trades around other cryptocurrency transactions.
Once the programs responded, the brothers allegedly exploited the software vulnerability to intercept private transaction information and substitute their own trades, redirecting approximately $25 million in cryptocurrency. Prosecutors said the operation took just 12 seconds and was followed by transfers through multiple cryptocurrency accounts to conceal the proceeds.
Judge's Reasoning
The government's case depended on whether the bait transactions and information submitted through the software amounted to deception under federal fraud law. Prosecutors argued that the brothers had deliberately misled automated trading programs into pursuing transactions that appeared profitable.
Clarke rejected the government's argument that submitting an invalid block header with a digital signature constituted fraud, finding insufficient evidence that the information influenced a material decision by the software system. The judge distinguished between manipulating a trading system in ways its developers had not intended and making a false representation punishable under federal law.
Legal Outcome
Federal authorities arrested the brothers in May 2024, accusing them of carrying out a novel scheme to exploit Ethereum's transaction-validation process. Their trial began in October 2025 and lasted nearly four weeks before Clarke declared a mistrial when jurors failed to reach a unanimous verdict on November 7.
Following the mistrial, defense attorneys sought an acquittal based on insufficient evidence. Clarke granted the request, concluding that the prosecution's case could not support a conviction even when viewed in the government's favor. The judgment of acquittal brings the federal criminal prosecution to an end and protects the brothers from being retried on the same charges under the Constitution's double jeopardy clause.