
Former USMNT coach says 'American sports reward losers' as he leaves for Manchester United
Mauricio Pochettino has left his post as head coach of the United States men's national team to take over at Manchester United, criticizing American sports for rewarding mediocrity.
Pochettino’s departure comes after a 26-month tenure in charge of the USMNT, a period marked by a significant shift in the team's mentality. His move to Manchester United represents a return to the high-pressure environment of European football, a stark contrast to the system he oversaw in the United States.
The Argentine coach, who led the team to the Round of 16 of the 2026 World Cup, has been critical of the American sports ecosystem. He argued that the structure of domestic soccer, particularly in Major League Soccer, fails to instill the necessary drive to win at the highest level.
Rewarding mediocrity
Pochettino highlighted the fundamental difference between European and American sports models. In Europe, losing can lead to relegation and the loss of a job, creating a survival instinct that drives teams to compete. In the US, he noted, the system cushions failure.
He pointed to the absence of promotion and relegation in MLS as a key factor. A team finishing at the bottom of the table does not face the threat of being sent down; instead, it is rewarded with a top draft pick. This setup, he argued, completely kills the instinct to fight for survival.
"If you start in MLS and you haven’t won a game in three months and you’re at the bottom, what’s the consequence if there’s no promotion or relegation, no international competition? Pochettino said. "Soccer is different: if you reward those who don’t win, if you don’t have goals, you don’t fight."
The coach further explained that without the threat of losing one's position, players and staff can become complacent. He noted that it took his team a year and a half to change the mentality of American players, who are disciplined but often lack the necessary grit for international competition.
Leadership and culture
Pochettino’s critique extended to the leadership structure of the team. He notably refused to give captain's armbands to star forward Christian Pulisic, instead favoring veteran Tim Ream for the 2026 World Cup and Tyler Adams in October. This decision came after Pulisic sat out the 2025 CONCACAF Gold Cup, a move that raised questions about his commitment.
The coach felt that the American media and public often graded the team on a soft curve, shielding them from the harsh realities of international standards. He insisted that he understood the football culture in the US but believed it needed to be tougher to produce champions.
Despite the team's progress in mentality, the 4-1 Round of 16 loss to Belgium in the 2026 World Cup demonstrated that changing a culture does not instantly close the talent gap with the world's elite. Pochettino acknowledged that a tougher attitude alone would not be enough to compete with the heavyweights.
Looking ahead
U.S. Soccer is now tasked with finding a successor to Pochettino. The federation has already begun looking at potential candidates, including Steve Cherundolo, B.J. Callaghan, and Pellegrino Matarazzo. The search could also include Pep Guardiola, whom Pochettino recommended for the position.
The challenge for the next coach will be to implement a system that demands excellence and holds players accountable. Until the USMNT stops protecting its players from the consequences of failure, the program is likely to remain an afterthought on the global stage.