Concurrence : l’UEFA et une fédération de grands clubs de football européens visées par une plainte
A group of European football clubs has filed an antitrust complaint with the European Union against UEFA and the European Club Association (EFC), claiming their exclusive agreement violates competition laws.
The Union of European Clubs (UEC) has lodged a complaint with the European Union against UEFA and the European Club Association (EFC), alleging that their exclusive agreement breaches European competition law. The UEC, representing non-elite clubs, claims the arrangement allows dominant teams like Paris Saint-Germain and Bayern Munich to consolidate their advantage in a sector generating tens of billions of euros annually.
Political challenges
The European Commission's Competition Directorate has historically been reluctant to investigate football-related matters, viewing them as politically sensitive. This contrasts with the Commission's generally frosty relationship with FIFA, though it has also been hesitant to formally investigate FIFA's international match calendar despite pressure from European lawmakers.
UEFA maintains good relations with the Commission, with President Aleksander Čeferin and European Commissioner for Sports Glenn Micallef renewing a cooperation agreement in Nyon, Switzerland last week.
Governance concerns
The UC bases part of its argument on a 2023 European Court of Justice ruling regarding the Super League, arguing that the principles governing UEFA's approval of competitions should apply to its agreement with EFC. The complaint highlights EFC's rules prohibiting members from joining other transnational club organizations without EFC, FIFA, or UEFA recognition.
With 920 members in men's and women's football, EFC is led by the powerful Qatari official Nasser al-Khelaïfi. The UEC claims small clubs have no significant influence within EFC, which designates 16 of the 20 members on UEFA's inter-club competitions committee.
Financial inequality
The UEC argues that European revenue distribution strengthens the advantage already enjoyed by top-tier clubs. A study cited by the organization estimates that an English club received 110 million euros from UEFA in a single season, roughly half the annual turnover of some of its Premier League rivals according to 2023 figures.
The UEC believes governance mechanisms and revenue distribution perpetuate this trend.
The UEC wants the Commission to obtain and publish the current memorandum of understanding between UEFA and EFC, and to order the removal of restrictive clauses, allowing other club bodies to be recognized and participate in the decision-making process.
The complaint follows an incident in May 2024 when a club was warned it would lose its EFC membership if it remained with the new organization. The UEC also claims 59 clubs have requested confidential UEC membership due to potential pressure.