
Italian regulator fines Meta $886 million for violating data privacy law
Italy's data protection authority has imposed a €805 million ($886 million) fine on Meta for accessing users' photos and videos without proper consent.
The fine, announced Saturday, is one of the biggest ever issued by the Italian data protection regulator. The investigation focused on Meta's 'camera roll' suggestions feature, launched in 2023, which browsed Android users' photo galleries to recommend posts they could enhance with personal content.
The regulator found Meta asked users for a single permission that applied across the entire app, failing to make clear they were consenting to camera roll suggestions. The feature was also allegedly turned on by default, allowing access to the entire photo library on a permanent basis.
Legal Basis
The practice violates Italian data protection regulations safeguarding 'the smartphone as part of the individual's private sphere.' According to the Garante, 'any access to the information stored on such devices requires free and informed consent, regardless of whether data is transmitted or any harm occurs.'
When given in full, such permission allows the app to access the entire photo library on the device, usually on a permanent basis, without the user or [regulators] being able to verify what information is actually being used.
Company Response
Meta had argued the Garante lacked jurisdiction to issue the fine, but the regulator dismissed that claim. A Meta spokesperson said the company 'strongly disagrees with the decision and plans to appeal what it called the 'disproportionate' fine amount.'
The tech giant has faced multiple legal challenges recently, including a $25 billion fine in October for deceiving consumers about data usage practices. In addition to the financial penalty, Meta must obtain separate consent for the camera roll feature and disable it by default within 60 days.