Supreme Court rejects Custodia Bank’s bid for Fed payment access
The US Supreme Court has declined to hear Wyoming crypto bank Custodia's appeal, ending its five-year fight for a Federal Reserve master account.
The refusal leaves a lower court ruling in place that found the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City had the authority to turn Custodia away. That authority now stands untouched, effectively ending the Wyoming crypto bank's long fight to plug directly into the Federal Reserve's payment system.
A five-year legal saga
Think of a master account as a membership card for the Fed's payment network. With one, a bank can move money directly on the central bank's rails. Without one, it has to rent access through another bank, which is slower, costlier, and leaves it dependent on a partner who can walk away.
Custodia is a special purpose depository institution, or SPDI, chartered in Wyoming. That charter type was designed for banks focused on digital assets. Custodia filed its master account application in October 2020, and the Kansas City Fed formally rejected it in January 2023.
The legal question at heart
The dispute centered on two laws: the Federal Reserve Act and the Monetary Control Act of 1980. The question was whether if a bank is eligible for Fed services, the Fed must provide them, or if eligibility merely puts the bank in line with the Fed deciding who actually gets in.
Inconsistent approach?
In March 2025, the same Kansas City Fed granted Kraken Financial a limited-purpose master account. Kraken Financial is also a crypto-focused institution, suggesting the Fed hasn't drawn a bright line against digital asset banks but is making case-by-case decisions.
To supporters of the Fed's position, that's exactly how discretion is supposed to work. Each application gets judged on its own risk profile. To critics, it looks inconsistent with similar businesses getting very different answers and little clarity on why.
Broader implications
The immediate loser is obvious. Custodia spent years and considerable legal effort chasing direct access, ending with nothing to show for it in court. The broader implications reach further, as any digital asset bank hoping to win a master account through litigation now faces a much steeper climb.
Future applicants will likely have to win over the Fed directly rather than count on judges to force its hand. The next pressure point is likely to be legislative rather than judicial. If Congress wants eligibility to guarantee access, it would need to write that into law explicitly.