
Johnson Controls Agrees $5m Cybersecurity Settlement Under False Claims Act - Lawyer Monthly
Johnson Controls Inc. and two subsidiaries have agreed to pay $5 million to resolve allegations of failing to comply with cybersecurity requirements under US federal contracts.
The allegations relate to contracts with NASA and the Departments of Defense, Energy and Justice, covering a period of more than seven years from January 2018 to August 2025. The case centers on whether failures to meet contractual cybersecurity obligations can give rise to liability under the False Claims Act, which allows the government to pursue claims involving fraud against federal funds.
Cybersecurity Failures
Federal prosecutors alleged that Johnson Controls failed to restrict access to protected information because they lacked sufficient knowledge of, or control over, their information systems. The allegations also concerned failures to maintain adequate security plans and properly develop or implement measures intended to correct identified weaknesses.
The contracts imposed different obligations depending on the agency involved. Certain Department of Defense agreements incorporated cybersecurity requirements under the Defense Federal Acquisition Regulation Supplement (DFARS), including provisions referring to National Institute of Standards and Technology Special Publication 800-171.
Security Plan Allegations
A substantial part of the allegations concerned two documents used to establish and monitor cybersecurity compliance: the System Security Plan and the plan of action and milestones. For contracts incorporating NIST SP 800-171, a System Security Plan describes the information system, its boundaries and operating environment, and how the contractor implements the required safeguards.
The government's settlement agreement alleges that Johnson Controls did not maintain a System Security Plan fully meeting the requirements of certain contracts. It also alleges that the companies failed to adequately document, develop or implement corrective action plans.
False Claims Act Context
The False Claims Act imposes civil liability for specified conduct involving knowingly false or fraudulent claims for government payment. The distinction was addressed by the US Supreme Court in Universal Health Services Inc. v United States ex rel. Escobar (2016), which held that the materiality requirement is demanding.
The fact that a contract identifies an obligation as a condition of payment is relevant, but does not automatically establish that a violation is material to the government's payment decision.
In the Johnson Controls matter, the government alleged that false claims were submitted, or caused to be submitted, in connection with the companies' failure to implement contractual cybersecurity requirements.
Whistleblower Settlement Details
The agreement resolves two lawsuits brought under the False Claims Act's qui tam provisions, initiated by former Johnson Controls employees Kelly Vance and David Thomas. Under the agreement, the companies must pay $5 million, together with interest calculated at an annual rate of 5% from June 12, 2026 until payment.
Of the $5 million principal, $2,428,565.80 is designated as restitution. The agreement provides for Vance to receive $850,000 from the government's recovery. It also requires separate payments of $135,000 to Vance's counsel and $163,750 to Thomas's counsel for legal fees, expenses and costs.
Contractual Obligations
Under the settlement's unallowable-cost provisions, Johnson Controls cannot charge certain expenses associated with the government's investigation, its legal defence, corrective actions undertaken in response to the investigation or the settlement itself to federal contracts.
The companies must identify any such costs previously included in requests for government payment and make the necessary adjustments or repayments within 90 days of the agreement's effective date. Federal authorities also retain the right to examine the relevant accounting records and challenge the amounts reported.