Judge lets DRAM cartel lawsuit against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron move forward
A federal judge in San Jose has rejected a motion to dismiss a class-action antitrust lawsuit against Samsung Electronics, SK Hynix, and Micron Technology, allowing the case to proceed to discovery.
For roughly a year, the only parties with any real say over memory chip prices were the three companies selling the chips. Now a federal judge in San Jose has a seat at the table too. US District Judge Noël Wise on November 14, 2026 refused to toss a class-action antitrust lawsuit against the three major chipmakers, opening the door to discovery where internal emails and planning documents will be examined.
The alleged conspiracy
The case was brought by 17 consumers and small businesses who allege the three chipmakers conspired to restrict the supply of conventional DRAM, the everyday memory that sits inside laptops, phones, and servers. These plaintiffs are indirect purchasers, meaning they bought finished products containing the chips rather than purchasing directly from the manufacturers.
The concentration at stake is hard to overstate. Together, the three defendants accounted for over 91% of global DRAM revenue in the third quarter of 2025. According to the complaint, production cuts began in late 2022, with SK Hynix reportedly moving first on October 26, 2022, followed by Micron approximately three weeks later, and Samsung joining in April 2023.
The plaintiffs also allege the companies redirected production away from conventional DRAM toward high-bandwidth memory (HBM), a premium tier designed for AI processors that carries higher margins. The result, per the complaint, was a squeeze on conventional DRAM, with prices surging by estimates ranging from approximately 500% to as high as 697%.
Judge's reasoning
A motion to dismiss is a defendant's attempt to end a case before it really starts, arguing that even if everything the plaintiffs say were true, it would not constitute a legal violation. Judge Wise found the allegations plausible, meaning the plaintiffs presented enough evidence to justify further investigation.
The ruling also distinguished this suit from an earlier case that had been dismissed. The judge pointed to the specific circumstances alleged here as setting it apart, which is why this one survived where the prior one did not.
Industry context
This is not the memory industry's first brush with cartel accusations. The defendants were involved in a prior DRAM price-fixing cartel that ran from 1998 to 2002 and ended with significant penalties. The backdrop is different this time, with the alleged motive tied to AI demand rather than PC memory.
The companies maintain that their production decisions reflected shifting market conditions, not collusion. Their formal answers to the lawsuit are due by December 7, 2026, with the first case-management conference set for January 12, 2027. For investors, the immediate impact is legal overhang rather than a verdict, as discovery can be lengthy and costly.