
Did prediction markets call the U.S. midterm election?: State of Crypto
Prediction markets largely matched polling data in the recent US midterm elections, with both correctly forecasting most outcomes except for three key races.
The recent US midterm elections have reignited a debate about the accuracy of prediction markets compared to traditional polling. Platforms like Kalshi and Polymarket have been tracking political outcomes for at least six election cycles, with their performance coming under particular scrutiny following the 2026 midterms.
Both prediction markets and polling data generally aligned in most key races tracked by CoinDesk, correctly projecting eventual winners. However, there were notable exceptions where both methods failed to predict the actual outcomes, highlighting limitations in these prediction approaches.
Mixed Results
In Wisconsin's First House District, both polls and prediction markets showed Rep. Bryan Steil and Democrat Mitchell Berman in a dead heat the week before the election. Steil ultimately lost to Berman. Similarly, in Alabama's Second House District, both methods incorrectly showed challenger Rhett Marques leading against Rep. Shomari Figures, who won the race.
The Iowa Senate race presented another discrepancy where prediction markets favored Rep. Ashley Hinson, while averaged polls showed a 50/50 split. State Rep. Josh Turek ultimately won, flipping the seat.
Unexpected Flips
Two Senate races demonstrated significant gaps between prediction methods and actual results. In Mississippi, Polymarket's contract favored incumbent Republican Cindy Hyde-Smith until vote results came in, while Kalshi had no contract for the contest. Similarly, South Carolina's Senate race had no Polymarket or Kalshi contract, though Polymarket offered a parlay for Montana, South Carolina and Mississippi Senate races.
Both races resulted in upsets as Democrats Scott Colom and Annie Andrews won their respective seats. Polling data for these races was limited, with The New York Times showing Senator Graham leading by 1 in South Carolina and no polls available for Mississippi, though other sources indicated narrow leads for Hyde-Smith.
Broader Implications
The performance of prediction markets in these elections raises questions about their reliability compared to traditional polling methods. While both approaches have their strengths, the unexpected outcomes in several races suggest neither provides complete certainty for closely contested elections.
As prediction markets continue to evolve, their role in forecasting political outcomes remains a subject of debate. The limited information available on certain races that resulted in upsets highlights the challenges both prediction markets and polls face in rapidly changing political landscapes.