
The ecological value of reintroducing white-tailed eagles to Britain | Letters
Experts defend reintroducing white-tailed eagles to Britain, arguing they historically coexisted with seabirds and their return restores lost ecological relationships.
A debate has emerged over the reintroduction of white-tailed eagles to Britain, with conservation experts challenging claims that the native predator threatens seabird colonies. Prof Ian Convery from the University of Cumbria argues that eagles and seabirds coexisted for thousands years before eagles were driven to extinction through human persecution.
Convery emphasizes that restoring eagles is not simply about recovering a charismatic species but about restoring lost ecological relationships and processes. He warns against accepting an 'ecologically impoverished landscape' as our conservation baseline, noting that seabird colonies have existed in the absence of a native apex predator but that doesn't make predator-free conditions either natural or desirable.
Research findings
Convery explains that Norwegian research cited in earlier reports doesn't demonstrate eagles cause 'wipeout' of seabird colonies. Rather, it documents how eagle disturbance can accelerate declines in colonies already experiencing food shortages. This distinction matters, as impacts appear greatest where seabirds struggle to find sufficient food.
If impacts are greatest where seabirds are struggling to find sufficient food, protecting prey availability must be central to conservation efforts.
Human impacts
Rebecca Wrigley, founder and CEO of Rewilding Britain, argues that Britain's seabird numbers are collapsing primarily due to overfishing, seabed degradation and climate change, which have reduced fish stocks. She contends that portraying the reintroduction of a native predator as a major conservation threat distracts from these human-driven factors.
Wrigley advocates for restoring natural habitats and ecological processes through rewilding, suggesting that framing native species' return as a threat delays vital ecosystem recovery. The Cumbrian White-tailed Eagle Project is currently exploring these questions through ecological research combined with community engagement to assess opportunities and risks of restoration.