Skip to main content

Nic Carter says most Bitcoin treasury firms offer little beyond ETF exposure

Crypto Briefing
15 lis 2026, 18:11Crypto
Oryginał
2 min read

Nic Carter, a general partner at Castle Island Ventures, argues that most Bitcoin treasury firms offer little value beyond what spot Bitcoin ETFs already provide.

Nic Carter has delivered a blunt assessment of Bitcoin treasury firms, arguing they provide little value beyond what investors can already obtain through spot Bitcoin ETFs. The Castle Island Ventures partner made this claim during an interview on October 27, 2026, challenging the business model of these digital asset treasury companies.

Bitcoin treasury firms, also known as digital asset treasury (DAT) companies, are public enterprises that hold Bitcoin as a core part of their corporate strategy. They typically pitch shareholders on gaining Bitcoin exposure plus additional benefits through their corporate structure.

The discount problem

The market appears to have reached a similar conclusion independently. Bitcoin treasury and DAT companies traded at discounts of approximately 40% to their net asset value in early 2026. This persistent discount suggests investors view the corporate wrapper as a cost rather than a benefit, aligning with Carter's argument that these structures often contribute little value.

The case against the middleman

Nic Carter, general partner at Castle Island Ventures

How the sector got here

The template for all Bitcoin treasury firms is Michael Saylor's MicroStrategy, now known as Strategy (ticker: MSTR), which pioneered the model of a public company holding Bitcoin as a treasury asset. Strategy's dominance continues due to the sheer size of its Bitcoin holdings, inspiring numerous imitators.

Between 2025 and 2026, scrutiny of the sector intensified, focusing on net asset value discounts and the sustainability of their business models. The arrival of spot Bitcoin ETFs sharpened these questions considerably, as ETFs provide a direct route to Bitcoin exposure without the added risks of corporate management and overhead.

What this means for investors

Treasury firms continue experimenting with capital structure innovations and new strategies, but clear evidence of substantial operational value beyond Bitcoin exposure remains elusive. The concentrated nature of the sector means larger players may better justify their structure through scale and track record, while smaller firms look most exposed to ETF competition.

Firms relying on yield-generation strategies to differentiate themselves now face skeptics like Zac Prince, who has questioned these approaches since early 2026 and drawn parallels to past Bitcoin yield schemes.

Z.ai
Article written by AI
Z.ai GLM-4.5-FlashFree
Free AI articles150 of 150
No limit after signing in with Telegram