
Backdoor subsidy for AI data centers? Cato analyst says let CHIPS Act tax credit expire - WBFF
A Cato Institute analyst is urging Congress to let a semiconductor manufacturing subsidy expire at year's end, calling it a backdoor AI subsidy amid voter backlash against data centers.
Adam Michel, the director of tax policy studies at the Cato Institute, isn't against data centers but believes the government shouldn't subsidize their inputs. He published an analysis this week advocating for the CHIPS and Science Act's advanced manufacturing investment tax credit to lapse at the end of the year.
Backdoor AI subsidy
The CHIPS Act, signed into law in 2022, subsidizes domestic semiconductor manufacturing, which Michel called 'the central components' of AI data centers. He contends the tax credit is effectively a backdoor AI subsidy, even as some in Congress call for a moratorium on data center expansion.
Schizophrenic policy
The two top members of the Senate Finance Committee have advocated for extending the CHIPS Act credit, calling it 'a critical tool for strengthening domestic semiconductor supply chains, creating good-paying jobs and advancing our national security interests.' However, one of those lawmakers, Oregon Sen. Ron Wyden, is simultaneously pushing for increased tax burdens on data centers.
Michel called this approach 'a pretty schizophrenic way of doing policy,' noting that extending the semiconductor tax credit would be 'quite counter to the anti-data center sentiment' currently running through the public.
Limited impact
Michel doesn't believe letting the CHIPS Act credit expire would significantly slow data center construction. Brookings Metro senior fellow Mark Muro agrees, calling it 'a weak tool' for managing data center growth. Both experts believe semiconductor fabrication and data center construction would see substantial investment regardless of the credit.
Muro suggested policymakers should focus on siting rules, utility rate design, and helping communities negotiate better deals to manage data center spread. His research shows communities can leverage the AI boom to secure long-term economic benefits.
Michel noted the credit's official cost has nearly tripled since the CHIPS Act became law four years ago, with a permanent extension potentially costing between $125 billion and $325 billion. He believes most semiconductor investments would have occurred anyway, making the credit essentially a 'windfall profit' for companies.
Market-driven growth
Michel emphasized that the surge in semiconductor and data center construction has been driven by market dynamics, not government incentives. He pointed to major companies like TSMC, Texas Instruments, Samsung and Intel announcing or breaking ground on domestic facilities in the year or two before the CHIPS Act credit existed.
Without congressional action, the semiconductor tax credit will expire at the end of this year, though projects already underway can claim the credit if placed in service within the next decade.